No one welcomes depression.

The brilliant writer Andrew Solomon describes his own severe depressive episode. “All I wanted was for “it” to stop; I could not have managed even to be so specific as to say what “it” was.” He quotes Emily Dickinson’s poem, the first line of which is haunting: “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain…”. 

You aren’t you any more.

I’ve been treated for depression twice in my lifetime. They both were moderate episodes; the first triggered by a terrible mistake of a marriage. The second was intricately woven into my experience of menopause. I went to therapy and took antidepressants. And I was lucky. I didn’t stop entirely functioning. My own perfectionism prevented that. But I well remember the feeling as I looked into the mirror that I didn’t really know the person looking back at me. Where had I gone?

Depression wears many faces. It can look like melancholy. It can look like agitation. It can be mild to much more severe, and even life-threatening. It can be masked by perfectionism, as it’s lying underneath that perfect-looking mask.. It can be triggered by trauma, past abuse, and neglect. It runs in families. It can be hidden behind addiction and anger.

But if you know ten adults statistically your chances that at least one of them (actually almost two) have dealt or are currently dealing with depression. And tragically, our children are becoming more and more depressed as the youngest generations experience more and more isolation, lost in their virtual lives.

Let’s talk about what some of the most common misconceptions about depression.

Seven common misconceptions about depression:

These questions are about all kinds of depression, from the familiar bipolar disorder to postpartum depression to others you may not have heard of, such as like “adjustment disorder” or “persistent depressive disorder.” Regardless of the type of depression, these misconceptions are pretty commonly held.

“If I can smile and laugh when something good or funny happens, does that mean I’m not depressed?”

Depression is on a spectrum. So if you’ve got a more moderate case, of course you can look and feel better for a while. You can go and enjoy your daughter’s birthday party, or smile and laugh when you reach a goal at work. But as soon as that event is over, you’re likely to feel that numbness or heaviness returning. And thinking becomes fuzzier and fuzzier over time. (Make sure you go to a doctor and rule out medical conditions, such as endocrine disorders, vitamin deficiencies, sleep disorders, circulatory disorders and others.) 

If you’re severely depressed, smiling and laughing, engaging with others may be almost impossible, as you try to fight off your own exhaustion and loss of stability.

“Is bipolar disorder the same thing as almost having two personalities? Is medication the only treatment?”

This question may seem naive, especially to someone who has the disorder. But no, it’s not that. Don’t get bipolar disorder confused with dissociative disorders where there can be distinct personas. If you have bipolar disorder, you do experience mood swings and may look and sound different when you’re “happier” or more sad.

Medicine is often needed to stabilize mood, but therapy can be very helpful to identify external and internal things that could trigger a swing – everything from lack of sleep or disturbed sleep patterns to certain situations where you might feel extra stress or pressure. Working on skills to help with impulse control and managing moods can be very important. Mood apps are great for this, so you can tangibly see what your moods do.

One man I worked who had bipolar disorder said, “If there’s one thing I’ve learned in therapy, it is to wait and not let my mood determine my next action. Even if only for day.”

“Does chronic depression, or what’s now termed “persistent depressive disorder” mean that you’re in a bad mood all the time?”

To be diagnosed with this as an adult, your sadness or low mood must last at least two years. So it might feel as if your bad mood is here to stay. You may rarely feel rested, and you tend to view things negatively.  You may take things too personally, feel victimized or as if there’s a target on your back.

I often say about PDD: “It sometimes isn’t until the lights come back on full force that you realize how they’ve slowing been fading, and you’ve been straining and squinting to see for years. It can happen that slowly.”

Identifying PDD for what it is can lead to you finally getting the help you need, and whatever shame you’ve had about your “bad mood” can be let go.

“What’s an adjustment disorder? Does this mean that you’re not snapping out of a reaction to something bad happening?”

If you’re depressed, you can’t stand to be told  to “snap out of it.”   An adjustment disorder is depression or ongoing sadness after something very painful has occurred, such as a divorce or an accident. It’s normal in many circumstances and it doesn’t mean you’re not resilient. It’s simply that you’ve met your emotional match and something has overwhelmed your skill set temporarily.

“Does postpartum depression happen only right after the birth of a child?”

No. It can happen then, but it can also emerge weeks to months after childbirth and it can happen when a second or third child is born even if everything was fine after a prior birth. A doctor or therapist needs to promptly identify it, for the sake of the mom, of course, but also for the baby. It can be mild but also much more severe, where a mom has lots of trouble attaching to or even caring about her baby. A spouse’s understanding and support is also vital so that shame doesn’t become part of the picture. Postpartum depression happens to more moms than you might imagine, up to one in seven.

Even doctors can discount or minimize its severity. This can have disastrous effects, because an infant feeling attached to, protected by, and nurtured by the mother is vital for their own sense of safety and well-being.

“Don’t all women get moody right before their periods? Is premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) a real thing?”

For any woman suffering from PMDD, this is a hurtful question. These women experience an emotional darkness before ovulation and/or before their periods that is truly paralyzing. It happens to three to eight percent of American women during the childbearing age, and can also look like anxiety, hostility and thinking problems. Obviously, there’s a hormonal influence here. But just think how it would feel to know that every two weeks or so, you’re going to risk losing your stability. It’s a very difficult disorder to have, especially when it’s severe.

“What’s a nervous breakdown?” 

This is an older term that was used to describe when your stress level was so high that it caused you to no longer be able to function. That might look like severe anxiety or seeing or hearing things that weren’t there or suicidal thoughts. It’s no longer used anymore; probably the nearest current diagnosis to it is what’s called an acute stress disorder, where you’ve been traumatized in some way that’s outside of your normal experience.

Hopefully you never have depression. But it’s not weakness. It’s not whining. It’s not you feeling sorry for yourself.

True depression is you not being you. And having the support and encouragement of those that love you can make all the difference.




You can hear more about mental health and many other topics by listening to my podcast, SelfWork with Dr. Margaret Rutherford. Subscribe to my website and receive one weekly newsletter including my weekly blog post and podcast! If you’d like to join my FaceBook closed group, then click here and answer the membership questions! Welcome!

My new book entitled Perfectly Hidden Depression has arrived and you can order here! Its message is specifically for those with a struggle with strong perfectionism which acts to mask underlying emotional pain. But the many self-help techniques described can be used by everyone who chooses to begin to address emotions long hidden away that are clouding and sabotaging your current life.

And there’s a new way to send me a message! You can record by clicking below and ask your question or make a comment. You’ll have 90 seconds to do so and that time goes quickly. By recording, you’re giving SelfWork (and me) permission to use your voice on the podcast. I’ll look forward to hearing from you!

Originally published on May 18, 2019; updated and republished on April 17, 2021.

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap